Angohind/Conversations: Difference between revisions

From Caves of Qud Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(forgot a node)
No edit summary
 
Line 1: Line 1:
[[Category:Conversations]]
{{As Of Patch|2.0.201.67}}
==Default==
==Default==
{{qud dialogue|nodetitle=Start
{{qud dialogue|nodetitle=Start
Line 8: Line 8:
{{live and drink}}}}
{{live and drink}}}}
==Kith and Kin==
==Kith and Kin==
{{qud dialogue|nodetitle=Start
{{Qud dialogue|nodetitle=Start
|text=Kendren! A moment of your time, please. You are =name=, yes? You seek to solve a mystery here in the village, yes?}}
|text=Kendren! A moment of your time, please. You are =name=, yes? You seek to solve a mystery here in the village, yes?}}
{{qud dialogue:choice|
{{Qud dialogue:choice|
{{qud dialogue:choice row|number = 1
{{Qud dialogue:choice row
| tonode=Introductions
|tonode=ShowSonnet
| text=I am, and yes.}}
|text=Does this poem belong to you?}}
{{!}}-
{{Qud dialogue:choice row
|tonode=Introductions
|text=I am, and yes.}}
{{!}}-
{{!}}-
{{qud dialogue:choice row|number = 2
{{Qud dialogue:choice row
| tonode=How did you know?
|tonode=How did you know?
| text=How did you know all that?}}
|text=How did you know all that?}}
{{!}}-
{{!}}-
{{qud dialogue:choice row|number = 3
{{Qud dialogue:choice row
| tonode=Introductions
|tonode=Introductions
| text=Who are you?}}
|text=Who are you?}}
{{!}}-
{{!}}-
{{qud dialogue:choice row|number = 4
{{Qud dialogue:choice row
| tonode=end
|tonode=End
| text=I don't have time for this. Live and drink.}}}}
|text=I don't have time for this. Live and drink.}}}}


{{qud dialogue|nodetitle=How did you know?
{{Qud dialogue|nodetitle=ShowSonnet
|text=Poem? Oh! This is a Shakespriggan sonnet, but I didn't write it--the rhymes are a bit facile, and love poems don't interest me.
 
I've been teaching Eskhind about sonnets, so she must have written this. But that means... oh, poor thing.}}
{{Qud dialogue:choice|
{{Qud dialogue:choice row
|tonode=End
|text=Thank you. Live and drink.}}}}
 
{{Qud dialogue|nodetitle=How did you know?
|text=I hoped you would ask! I closely study the works of the great bard, Willow Shakesprig. In particular, I am most fond of the stories of the Great Plant Detective, Hemlock Cones. Through these stories, I have learned to hone my perceptions and deductive skill to a fine point. It is my dearest hope that one day I shall be known not as Angohind, village bookworm... but Angohind, Master Detective.
|text=I hoped you would ask! I closely study the works of the great bard, Willow Shakesprig. In particular, I am most fond of the stories of the Great Plant Detective, Hemlock Cones. Through these stories, I have learned to hone my perceptions and deductive skill to a fine point. It is my dearest hope that one day I shall be known not as Angohind, village bookworm... but Angohind, Master Detective.


My grandhind has forbidden me from looking into the strange doings in the village, but she said nothing about me teaching you the ins and outs of detective work! What say you?}}
My grandhind has forbidden me from looking into the strange doings in the village, but she said nothing about me teaching you the ins and outs of detective work! What say you?}}
{{qud dialogue:choice|
{{Qud dialogue:choice|
{{qud dialogue:choice row|number = 1
{{Qud dialogue:choice row
| tonode=Acceptance
|tonode=Acceptance
| text=I am listening.}}
|text=I am listening.}}
{{!}}-
{{!}}-
{{qud dialogue:choice row|number = 2
{{Qud dialogue:choice row
| tonode=end
|tonode=End
| text=I should... go. Live and drink.}}}}
|text=I should... go. Live and drink.}}}}
 
{{Qud dialogue|nodetitle=Introductions
{{qud dialogue|nodetitle=Introductions
|text=Yes, yes of course.
|text=Yes, yes of course.


Line 46: Line 58:


My grandhind has forbidden me from looking into the strange doings in the village, but she said nothing about me teaching you the ins and outs of detective work! What say you?}}
My grandhind has forbidden me from looking into the strange doings in the village, but she said nothing about me teaching you the ins and outs of detective work! What say you?}}
{{qud dialogue:choice|
{{Qud dialogue:choice|
{{qud dialogue:choice row|number = 1
{{Qud dialogue:choice row
| tonode=Acceptance
|tonode=Acceptance
| text=I am listening.}}
|text=I am listening.}}
{{!}}-
{{!}}-
{{qud dialogue:choice row|number = 2
{{Qud dialogue:choice row
| tonode=end
|tonode=End
| text=No thank you. Live and drink.}}}}
|text=No thank you. Live and drink.}}}}
 
{{Qud dialogue|nodetitle=Acceptance
{{qud dialogue|nodetitle=Acceptance
|text=Oh, truly? You won't regret this, kendren, I promise! So, let's get to it!
|text=Oh, truly? You won't regret this, kendren, I promise! So, let's get to it!


Every mystery hinges on the detection and interpretation of evidence. As Hemlock Cones said:
Every mystery hinges on the detection and interpretation of evidence. As Hemlock Cones said:


  Ere any prosecution can commence,
Ere any prosecution can commence,
  Accusers must obtain some evidence.
Accusers must obtain some evidence.
  The solving lies in seeing and locating
The solving lies in seeing and locating
  Supporting clues as well as implicating.}}
Supporting clues as well as implicating.}}
{{qud dialogue:choice|
{{Qud dialogue:choice|
{{qud dialogue:choice row|number = 1
{{Qud dialogue:choice row
| tonode=Finding evidence
|tonode=Finding evidence
| text=How do I find evidence?}}
|text=How do I find evidence?}}
{{!}}-
{{Qud dialogue:choice row
|tonode=Defining evidence
|text=What makes something evidence?}}
{{!}}-
{{!}}-
{{qud dialogue:choice row|number = 2
{{Qud dialogue:choice row
| tonode=Implicating evidence
|tonode=Implicating evidence
| text=What is implicating evidence?}}
|text=What is implicating evidence?}}
{{!}}-
{{!}}-
{{qud dialogue:choice row|number = 3
{{Qud dialogue:choice row
| tonode=Supporting evidence
|tonode=Supporting evidence
| text=What is supporting evidence?}}
|text=What is supporting evidence?}}
{{!}}-
{{!}}-
{{qud dialogue:choice row|number = 4
{{Qud dialogue:choice row
| tonode=Multiple culprits?
|tonode=Multiple culprits?
| text=What if evidence indicates multiple culprits?}}}}
|text=What if evidence indicates multiple culprits?}}}}
 
{{Qud dialogue|nodetitle=Finding evidence
{{qud dialogue|nodetitle=Finding evidence
|text=Professor Cones taught me everything about finding evidence!
|text=Professor Cones taught me everything about finding evidence!


  Though evidence you found upon the ground may yet be sound,
Though evidence you found upon the ground may yet be sound,
  If it will be sufficient is a toss-up.
If it will be sufficient is a toss-up.
  Examine all your suspects and their homes and all around,
Examine all your suspects and their homes and all around,
  And find a witness who may dish the gossip.
And find a witness who may dish the gossip.


You can find evidence by looking at things on the ground, but you can also look at your suspects to see if there's anything off about them. You can also ask around to see if anyone has seen or heard anything strange, and different witnesses may have different things to report.}}
You can find evidence by looking at things on the ground, but you can also look at your suspects to see if there's anything off about them. You can also ask around to see if anyone has seen or heard anything strange, and different witnesses may have different things to report.}}
{{qud dialogue:choice|
{{Qud dialogue:choice|
{{qud dialogue:choice row|number = 1
{{Qud dialogue:choice row
| tonode=Implicating evidence
|tonode=Supporting evidence
| text=What is implicating evidence?}}
|text=What about supporting evidence?}}
{{!}}-
{{!}}-
{{qud dialogue:choice row|number = 2
{{Qud dialogue:choice row
| tonode=Supporting evidence
|tonode=Defining evidence
| text=What is supporting evidence?}}
|text=What makes something evidence?}}
{{!}}-
{{!}}-
{{qud dialogue:choice row|number = 3
{{Qud dialogue:choice row
| tonode=Multiple culprits?
|tonode=Multiple culprits?
| text=What if I find implicating evidence for multiple suspects?}}
|text=What if I find implicating evidence for multiple suspects?}}
{{!}}-
{{!}}-
{{qud dialogue:choice row|number = 4
{{Qud dialogue:choice row
| tonode=end
|tonode=End
| text=Thank you for your help, Angohind. Live and drink.}}}}
|text=Thank you for your help, Angohind. Live and drink.}}}}
{{Qud dialogue|nodetitle=Defining evidence
|text=Evidence is any sign of something gone amiss. The Great Plant Detective gave some good examples in Act II of the tragedy of Gimlet:


{{qud dialogue|nodetitle=Implicating evidence
So! Sweep the full estate for signs of {{Qud shader no parse|W|trade}},
|text=Implicating evidence is what it sounds like: evidence that implicates someone's involvement in a crime. For example, if someone observed strange behavior in a person, or if you found something weird in a person's room, or even if you observe them behaving strangely yourself! That's implicating evidence.
their shady night-time dealings to expose
Now look for signs of {{Qud shader no parse|W|craft}}, see what was made
For to conceal a treasure hidden close.
But darker still, if {{Qud shader no parse|W|illness}} signs we find
A desperate contagion may yet lurk
And darkest yet, more {{Qud shader no parse|W|violence}} may reply
To those who stumble 'pon their grisly work.}}
{{Qud dialogue:choice|
{{Qud dialogue:choice row
|tonode=Finding evidence
|text=How do I find evidence?}}
{{!}}-
{{Qud dialogue:choice row
|tonode=Defining evidence
|text=What makes something evidence?}}
{{!}}-
{{Qud dialogue:choice row
|tonode=Implicating evidence
|text=What is implicating evidence?}}
{{!}}-
{{Qud dialogue:choice row
|tonode=Supporting evidence
|text=What is supporting evidence?}}
{{!}}-
{{Qud dialogue:choice row
|tonode=Multiple culprits?
|text=What if evidence indicates multiple culprits?}}}}
{{Qud dialogue|nodetitle=Implicating evidence
|text=Implicating evidence is what it sounds like: evidence that implicates someone's involvement in a crime. For example, if someone observed strange behavior in a person, or if you found something weird in a person's room, or even if you observe them behaving strangely =player.reflexive=! That's implicating evidence.


Most of the time, a piece of implicating evidence isn't proof of a crime in and of itself, but when presented alongside supporting evidence, implicating evidence is the seed of truth from which grows the long frond of justice.}}
Most of the time, a piece of implicating evidence isn't proof of a crime in and of itself, but when presented alongside supporting evidence, implicating evidence is the seed of truth from which grows the long frond of justice.}}
{{qud dialogue:choice|
{{Qud dialogue:choice|
{{qud dialogue:choice row|number = 1
{{Qud dialogue:choice row
| tonode=Supporting evidence
|tonode=Supporting evidence
| text=What is supporting evidence?}}
|text=What about supporting evidence?}}
{{!}}-
{{!}}-
{{qud dialogue:choice row|number = 2
{{Qud dialogue:choice row
| tonode=Finding evidence
|tonode=Finding evidence
| text=How do I find evidence?}}
|text=How do I find evidence?}}
{{!}}-
{{!}}-
{{qud dialogue:choice row|number = 3
{{Qud dialogue:choice row
| tonode=Multiple culprits?
|tonode=Multiple culprits?
| text=What if I find implicating evidence for multiple suspects?}}
|text=What if I find implicating evidence for multiple suspects?}}
{{!}}-
{{!}}-
{{qud dialogue:choice row|number = 4
{{Qud dialogue:choice row
| tonode=end
|tonode=End
| text=Thank you for your help, Angohind. Live and drink.}}}}
|text=Thank you for your help, Angohind. Live and drink.}}}}
 
{{Qud dialogue|nodetitle=Supporting evidence
{{qud dialogue|nodetitle=Supporting evidence
|text=Supporting evidence can be any sign that something is amiss that you can't directly tie to an individual. One common example is a bloodstain, which indicates that violence was committed but doesn't tell you by whom.
|text=Supporting evidence can be any sign that something is amiss that you can't directly tie to an individual. One common example is a bloodstain, which indicates that violence was committed but doesn't tell you by whom.


At its heart, supporting evidence is most powerful when paired with implicating evidence. Once you have both, you'll be in a good position to accuse a suspect of wrongdoing.}}
At its heart, supporting evidence is most powerful when paired with implicating evidence. Once you have both, you'll be in a good position to accuse a suspect of wrongdoing.}}
{{qud dialogue:choice|
{{Qud dialogue:choice|
{{qud dialogue:choice row|number = 1
{{Qud dialogue:choice row
| tonode=Implicating evidence
|tonode=Implicating evidence
| text=What is implicating evidence?}}
|text=What about implicating evidence?}}
{{!}}-
{{!}}-
{{qud dialogue:choice row|number = 2
{{Qud dialogue:choice row
| tonode=Finding evidence
|tonode=Finding evidence
| text=How do I find evidence?}}
|text=How do I find evidence?}}
{{!}}-
{{!}}-
{{qud dialogue:choice row|number = 3
{{Qud dialogue:choice row
| tonode=Multiple culprits?
|tonode=Multiple culprits?
| text=What if I find implicating evidence for multiple suspects?}}
|text=What if I find implicating evidence for multiple suspects?}}
{{!}}-
{{!}}-
{{qud dialogue:choice row|number = 4
{{Qud dialogue:choice row
| tonode=end
|tonode=End
| text=Thank you for your help, Angohind. Live and drink.}}}}
|text=Thank you for your help, Angohind. Live and drink.}}}}
 
{{Qud dialogue|nodetitle=Multiple culprits?
{{qud dialogue|nodetitle=Multiple culprits?
|text=As Professor Cones said:
|text=As Professor Cones said:


  We know the reach of law, however long,
We know the reach of law, however long,
  Is not the finest judge of right and wrong.
Is not the finest judge of right and wrong.
  Choose not what evidence thou wilt present
Choose not what evidence thou wilt present
  Ere its consequence is evident.
Ere its consequence is evident.


In short, you must use your judgment and intuition, kendren.}}
In short, you must use your judgment and intuition, kendren.}}
{{qud dialogue:choice|
{{Qud dialogue:choice|
{{qud dialogue:choice row|number = 1
{{Qud dialogue:choice row
| tonode=Evidence exceptions
|tonode=Evidence exceptions
| text=What if I accuse the wrong person?}}
|text=What if I accuse the wrong person?}}
{{!}}-
{{!}}-
{{qud dialogue:choice row|number = 2
{{Qud dialogue:choice row
| tonode=Evidence is not created equal
|tonode=Evidence is not created equal
| text=You're saying that what evidence I choose to show will affect the outcome of the case?}}
|text=You're saying that what evidence I choose to show will affect the outcome of the case?}}
{{!}}-
{{!}}-
{{qud dialogue:choice row|number = 3
{{Qud dialogue:choice row
| tonode=Gaming the system
|tonode=Gaming the system
| text=Then what's to keep me from simply choosing the outcome I want?}}
|text=Then what's to keep me from simply choosing the outcome I want?}}
{{!}}-
{{!}}-
{{qud dialogue:choice row|number = 4
{{Qud dialogue:choice row
| tonode=Questions
|tonode=Questions
| text=I have further questions.}}}}
|text=I have further questions.}}}}
 
{{Qud dialogue|nodetitle=Evidence exceptions
{{qud dialogue|nodetitle=Evidence exceptions
|text=That's always a risk, kendren.
|text=That's always a risk, kendren.


Line 181: Line 222:


If you make too many bad accusations, you might lose credibility with her entirely.}}
If you make too many bad accusations, you might lose credibility with her entirely.}}
{{qud dialogue:choice|
{{Qud dialogue:choice|
{{qud dialogue:choice row|number = 1
{{Qud dialogue:choice row
| tonode=Questions
|tonode=Questions
| text=I see. I have further questions.}}
|text=I see. I have further questions.}}
{{!}}-
{{!}}-
{{qud dialogue:choice row|number = 2
{{Qud dialogue:choice row
| tonode=end
|tonode=End
| text=Thank you for the help, Angohind. Live and drink.}}}}
|text=Thank you for the help, Angohind. Live and drink.}}}}
 
{{Qud dialogue|nodetitle=Gaming the system
{{qud dialogue|nodetitle=Gaming the system
|text=Well, your conscience, surely.
|text=Well, your conscience, surely.


You wouldn't be so unethical as to manipulate the resolution of a crime to your own ends. W-would you?}}
You wouldn't be so unethical as to manipulate the resolution of a crime to your own ends. W-would you?}}
{{qud dialogue:choice|
{{Qud dialogue:choice|
{{qud dialogue:choice row|number = 1
{{Qud dialogue:choice row
| tonode=Questions
|tonode=Questions
| text=As you say it. I have further questions.}}
|text=As you say it. I have further questions.}}
{{!}}-
{{!}}-
{{qud dialogue:choice row|number = 2
{{Qud dialogue:choice row
| tonode=end
|tonode=End
| text=Well, I should get going. Live and drink.}}}}
|text=Well, I should get going. Live and drink.}}}}
 
{{Qud dialogue|nodetitle=Evidence is not created equal
{{qud dialogue|nodetitle=Evidence is not created equal
|text=Precisely. The evidence you present paints a picture that will forever hang in the halls of Bey Lah's history. Our fate is in your hands.
|text=Precisely. The evidence you present paints a picture that will forever hang in the halls of Bey Lah's history. Our fate is in your hands.


Hemlock Cones once said:
Hemlock Cones once said:


  As like begets like in daily life
As like begets like in daily life
  so too in mystery.
so too in mystery.
  Should I paint pictures full of strife
Should I paint pictures full of strife
  thus violence comes to be.
thus violence comes to be.
  If I in craft or trade should deal
If I in craft or trade should deal
  then deals shall deal by troth
then deals shall deal by troth
  But if I pestilence reveal-
But if I pestilence reveal-
  no honey be enough.}}
no honey be enough.}}
{{qud dialogue:choice|
{{Qud dialogue:choice|
{{qud dialogue:choice row|number = 1
{{Qud dialogue:choice row
| tonode=Questions
|tonode=Questions
| text=I see. I have further questions.}}
|text=I see. I have further questions.}}
{{!}}-
{{!}}-
{{qud dialogue:choice row|number = 2
{{Qud dialogue:choice row
| tonode=end
|tonode=End
| text=Thank you for the help, Angohind. Live and drink.}}}}
|text=Thank you for your help, Angohind. Live and drink.}}}}
 
{{Qud dialogue|nodetitle=Questions
{{qud dialogue|nodetitle=Questions
|text=Please, ask away!}}
|text=Please, ask away!}}
{{qud dialogue:choice|
{{Qud dialogue:choice|
{{qud dialogue:choice row|number = 1
{{Qud dialogue:choice row
| tonode=Finding evidence
|tonode=Finding evidence
| text=How do I find evidence?}}
|text=How do I find evidence?}}
{{!}}-
{{!}}-
{{qud dialogue:choice row|number = 2
{{Qud dialogue:choice row
| tonode=Implicating evidence
|tonode=Implicating evidence
| text=What is implicating evidence?}}
|text=What is implicating evidence?}}
{{!}}-
{{!}}-
{{qud dialogue:choice row|number = 3
{{Qud dialogue:choice row
| tonode=Supporting evidence
|tonode=Supporting evidence
| text=What is supporting evidence?}}
|text=What is supporting evidence?}}
{{!}}-
{{!}}-
{{qud dialogue:choice row|number = 4
{{Qud dialogue:choice row
| tonode=Multiple culprits?
|tonode=Multiple culprits?
| text=What if evidence indicates multiple culprits?}}
|text=What if evidence indicates multiple culprits?}}
{{!}}-
{{!}}-
{{qud dialogue:choice row|number = 5
{{Qud dialogue:choice row
| tonode=Evidence exceptions
|tonode=Evidence exceptions
| text=What if I accuse the wrong person?}}
|text=What if I accuse the wrong person?}}
{{!}}-
{{!}}-
{{qud dialogue:choice row|number = 6
{{Qud dialogue:choice row
| tonode=end
|tonode=End
| text=That is all. Live and drink, faundren.}}}}
|text=That is all. Live and drink, faundren.}}}}


==Kith and Kin Outcome: Hindriarch Keh==
==Outcomes==
{{qud dialogue|nodetitle=Start
{{qud dialogue|nodetitle=Hindriarch Keh
|text=You should be proud, Detective =name=.
|text=You should be proud, Detective =name=.


The hand of justice can be harsh, but it is fair. You have been its agent here.}}
The hand of justice can be harsh, but it is fair. You have been its agent here.}}
{{qud dialogue:choice|
{{Qud dialogue|nodetitle=Hindriarch Keh, fully resolved
{{live and drink}}}}
|text=Welcome back, Detective =name=.


==Kith and Kin Outcome: Hindriarch Eskhind==
Everything's in order here, more or less.}}
{{qud dialogue|nodetitle=Start
{{qud dialogue|nodetitle=Hindriarch Esk
|text=Stunning! Eskhind as Hindriarch?
|text=Stunning! Eskhind as Hindriarch?


Those poetry lessons I had been giving her must have inspired in her a sense of civic duty.}}
Those poetry lessons I had been giving her must have inspired in her a sense of civic duty.}}
{{qud dialogue:choice|
{{live and drink}}}}


==Kith and Kin Outcome: No Hindriarch==
{{Qud dialogue|nodetitle=Hindriarch Esk, fully resolved
{{qud dialogue|nodetitle=Start
|text=So much change! I've been investigating the 'Democracy' that Hindriarch Esk has been espousing, and it strikes me as rife with vulnerabilities to malicious actors. Perhaps it can be refined.}}
 
{{qud dialogue|nodetitle=Village Ravaged
|text=Is this really the world we live in?
|text=Is this really the world we live in?


How cruel.}}
How cruel.}}
{{qud dialogue:choice|
[[Category:Conversations]]
{{live and drink}}}}

Latest revision as of 23:04, 31 January 2021

This information is reliable as of patch 2.0.201.67. If this is no longer the current patch, you can help by updating it.
As of Patch This information is reliable as of patch 2.0.201.67.

Default

Start

[ Angohind ]

Something strange is afoot here in Bey Lah, and no mistake.

But I am forbidden from investigating. If only there were another detective that I could advise...

1) Live and drink. [End]

Kith and Kin

Start

[ Angohind ]

Kendren! A moment of your time, please. You are =name=, yes? You seek to solve a mystery here in the village, yes?

1) Does this poem belong to you?
2) I am, and yes.
3) How did you know all that?
4) Who are you?
5) I don't have time for this. Live and drink. [End]

ShowSonnet

[ Angohind ]

Poem? Oh! This is a Shakespriggan sonnet, but I didn't write it--the rhymes are a bit facile, and love poems don't interest me.

I've been teaching Eskhind about sonnets, so she must have written this. But that means... oh, poor thing.

1) Thank you. Live and drink. [End]

How did you know?

[ Angohind ]

I hoped you would ask! I closely study the works of the great bard, Willow Shakesprig. In particular, I am most fond of the stories of the Great Plant Detective, Hemlock Cones. Through these stories, I have learned to hone my perceptions and deductive skill to a fine point. It is my dearest hope that one day I shall be known not as Angohind, village bookworm... but Angohind, Master Detective.

My grandhind has forbidden me from looking into the strange doings in the village, but she said nothing about me teaching you the ins and outs of detective work! What say you?

1) I am listening.
2) I should... go. Live and drink. [End]

Introductions

[ Angohind ]

Yes, yes of course.

I am Angohind: grandson of esteemed Elder Eselhind, young scholar of Shakesprig, and best dressed hindren in Bey Lah. I am also, as luck would have it, an aspirant investigator with an ear... for mystery.

My grandhind has forbidden me from looking into the strange doings in the village, but she said nothing about me teaching you the ins and outs of detective work! What say you?

1) I am listening.
2) No thank you. Live and drink. [End]

Acceptance

[ Angohind ]

Oh, truly? You won't regret this, kendren, I promise! So, let's get to it!

Every mystery hinges on the detection and interpretation of evidence. As Hemlock Cones said:

Ere any prosecution can commence,
Accusers must obtain some evidence.
The solving lies in seeing and locating
Supporting clues as well as implicating.

1) How do I find evidence?
2) What makes something evidence?
3) What is implicating evidence?
4) What is supporting evidence?
5) What if evidence indicates multiple culprits?

Finding evidence

[ Angohind ]

Professor Cones taught me everything about finding evidence!

Though evidence you found upon the ground may yet be sound,
If it will be sufficient is a toss-up.
Examine all your suspects and their homes and all around,
And find a witness who may dish the gossip.

You can find evidence by looking at things on the ground, but you can also look at your suspects to see if there's anything off about them. You can also ask around to see if anyone has seen or heard anything strange, and different witnesses may have different things to report.

1) What about supporting evidence?
2) What makes something evidence?
3) What if I find implicating evidence for multiple suspects?
4) Thank you for your help, Angohind. Live and drink. [End]

Defining evidence

[ Angohind ]

Evidence is any sign of something gone amiss. The Great Plant Detective gave some good examples in Act II of the tragedy of Gimlet:

So! Sweep the full estate for signs of trade,
their shady night-time dealings to expose
Now look for signs of craft, see what was made
For to conceal a treasure hidden close.
But darker still, if illness signs we find
A desperate contagion may yet lurk
And darkest yet, more violence may reply
To those who stumble 'pon their grisly work.

1) How do I find evidence?
2) What makes something evidence?
3) What is implicating evidence?
4) What is supporting evidence?
5) What if evidence indicates multiple culprits?

Implicating evidence

[ Angohind ]

Implicating evidence is what it sounds like: evidence that implicates someone's involvement in a crime. For example, if someone observed strange behavior in a person, or if you found something weird in a person's room, or even if you observe them behaving strangely (player's reflexive)! That's implicating evidence.

Most of the time, a piece of implicating evidence isn't proof of a crime in and of itself, but when presented alongside supporting evidence, implicating evidence is the seed of truth from which grows the long frond of justice.

1) What about supporting evidence?
2) How do I find evidence?
3) What if I find implicating evidence for multiple suspects?
4) Thank you for your help, Angohind. Live and drink. [End]

Supporting evidence

[ Angohind ]

Supporting evidence can be any sign that something is amiss that you can't directly tie to an individual. One common example is a bloodstain, which indicates that violence was committed but doesn't tell you by whom.

At its heart, supporting evidence is most powerful when paired with implicating evidence. Once you have both, you'll be in a good position to accuse a suspect of wrongdoing.

1) What about implicating evidence?
2) How do I find evidence?
3) What if I find implicating evidence for multiple suspects?
4) Thank you for your help, Angohind. Live and drink. [End]

Multiple culprits?

[ Angohind ]

As Professor Cones said:

We know the reach of law, however long,
Is not the finest judge of right and wrong.
Choose not what evidence thou wilt present
Ere its consequence is evident.

In short, you must use your judgment and intuition, kendren.

1) What if I accuse the wrong person?
2) You're saying that what evidence I choose to show will affect the outcome of the case?
3) Then what's to keep me from simply choosing the outcome I want?
4) I have further questions.

Evidence exceptions

[ Angohind ]

That's always a risk, kendren.

Neelahind knows everyone in the village very well. If you present supporting evidence that contradicts something the Warden knows to be true about the suspect, well, she probably won't believe you. In fact, she might not let you accuse that person again, so be careful.

If you make too many bad accusations, you might lose credibility with her entirely.

1) I see. I have further questions.
2) Thank you for the help, Angohind. Live and drink. [End]

Gaming the system

[ Angohind ]

Well, your conscience, surely.

You wouldn't be so unethical as to manipulate the resolution of a crime to your own ends. W-would you?

1) As you say it. I have further questions.
2) Well, I should get going. Live and drink. [End]

Evidence is not created equal

[ Angohind ]

Precisely. The evidence you present paints a picture that will forever hang in the halls of Bey Lah's history. Our fate is in your hands.

Hemlock Cones once said:

As like begets like in daily life
so too in mystery.
Should I paint pictures full of strife
thus violence comes to be.
If I in craft or trade should deal
then deals shall deal by troth
But if I pestilence reveal-
no honey be enough.

1) I see. I have further questions.
2) Thank you for your help, Angohind. Live and drink. [End]

Questions

[ Angohind ]

Please, ask away!

1) How do I find evidence?
2) What is implicating evidence?
3) What is supporting evidence?
4) What if evidence indicates multiple culprits?
5) What if I accuse the wrong person?
6) That is all. Live and drink, faundren. [End]

Outcomes

Hindriarch Keh

[ Angohind ]

You should be proud, Detective =name=.

The hand of justice can be harsh, but it is fair. You have been its agent here.

Hindriarch Keh, fully resolved

[ Angohind ]

Welcome back, Detective =name=.

Everything's in order here, more or less.

Hindriarch Esk

[ Angohind ]

Stunning! Eskhind as Hindriarch?

Those poetry lessons I had been giving her must have inspired in her a sense of civic duty.


Hindriarch Esk, fully resolved

[ Angohind ]

So much change! I've been investigating the 'Democracy' that Hindriarch Esk has been espousing, and it strikes me as rife with vulnerabilities to malicious actors. Perhaps it can be refined.


Village Ravaged

[ Angohind ]

Is this really the world we live in?

How cruel.